The New York City FC and New York Red Bulls rivalry, often called the Hudson River Derby, is one of the most compelling and hotly contested in Major League Soccer. While the Red Bulls, established in 1996 as the MetroStars, predate NYCFC (founded in 2013), the derby atmosphere ignited almost immediately upon NYCFC’s arrival, fueled by geographic proximity, passionate supporters, and the inherent desire to be the top team in the Big Apple.
The rivalry is more than just a local affair; it’s a clash of identities. The Red Bulls, originally playing in Giants Stadium and now in Harrison, New Jersey, have long been seen as the established team, representing the broader New York metropolitan area. NYCFC, on the other hand, made their home at Yankee Stadium in the Bronx, forging a direct connection to a specific borough and embracing a more urban, “New York City” brand. This contrast is evident in their fan bases, with NYCFC drawing heavily from city residents and a more diverse, younger demographic, while the Red Bulls boast a loyal following throughout the region.
On the pitch, the Hudson River Derby has produced its share of memorable moments. Early matches were often dominated by the Red Bulls, who leveraged their experience and more consistent form. However, NYCFC gradually closed the gap, achieving their first derby win in 2015 and eventually surpassing the Red Bulls in terms of on-field success. The 2021 season was a defining moment for NYCFC, as they not only defeated the Red Bulls in the playoffs but went on to win their first MLS Cup, cementing their status as a genuine force in the league.
Beyond the victories and defeats, the intensity of the rivalry is fueled by individual player matchups, tactical battles, and the unwavering support of both fan bases. Matches are characterized by hard tackles, passionate celebrations, and an electric atmosphere. The supporters groups, such as NYCFC’s “Third Rail” and the Red Bulls’ “Empire Supporters Club,” play a crucial role in creating the derby’s unique ambiance, with elaborate displays, chants, and unwavering support for their respective teams.
While the Red Bulls have historically had a slight edge in the overall head-to-head record, the recent success of NYCFC has added another layer of complexity to the rivalry. Both teams consistently strive to outdo each other, not just on the field but also in terms of player acquisitions, stadium improvements, and overall fan engagement. The Hudson River Derby is more than just a game; it’s a symbol of New York’s competitive spirit, the passion of its soccer fans, and the ever-evolving landscape of Major League Soccer.